Would you rather Scary

Scary Would You Rather Questions

These scary would you rather questions are made for flashlight-under-the-chin moments. They cover haunted places, creepy creatures, strange noises at night and how you'd make it through a spooky story. Everything stays spooky, never gory, so they suit sleepovers, campfires and teens who like a good chill.

Each question is a live poll. Tap a side to vote, then see how everyone else voted. Some picks are about which fear you can handle, and some are about which one you'd rather never face.

50 questions · tap a side to vote · see how everyone else picked

Scary would you rather questions about haunted places

Lighthouses, castles, ghost ships and houses with rules you shouldn't break.

  1. 1Would you rather

    or

  2. 2Would you rather

    or

  3. 3Would you rather

    or

  4. 4Would you rather

    or

  5. 5Would you rather

    or

  6. 6Would you rather

    or

  7. 7Would you rather

    or

  8. 8Would you rather

    or

  9. 9Would you rather

    or

  10. 10Would you rather

    or

  11. 11Would you rather

    or

  12. 12Would you rather

    or

  13. 13Would you rather

    or

Creepy would you rather questions about spooky creatures

Some of these creatures are frightening, and some just need a little help.

  1. 14Would you rather

    or

  2. 15Would you rather

    or

  3. 16Would you rather

    or

  4. 17Would you rather

    or

  5. 18Would you rather

    or

  6. 19Would you rather

    or

  7. 20Would you rather

    or

  8. 21Would you rather

    or

  9. 22Would you rather

    or

  10. 23Would you rather

    or

  11. 24Would you rather

    or

  12. 25Would you rather

    or

Spooky would you rather questions for dark nights

Strange sounds, flickering lights and the long walk home after sunset.

  1. 26Would you rather

    or

  2. 27Would you rather

    or

  3. 28Would you rather

    or

  4. 29Would you rather

    or

  5. 30Would you rather

    or

  6. 31Would you rather

    or

  7. 32Would you rather

    or

  8. 33Would you rather

    or

  9. 34Would you rather

    or

  10. 35Would you rather

    or

  11. 36Would you rather

    or

  12. 37Would you rather

    or

  13. 38Would you rather

    or

Scary would you rather questions: survival what-ifs

Pick the spooky situation you think you could actually get through.

  1. 39Would you rather

    or

  2. 40Would you rather

    or

  3. 41Would you rather

    or

  4. 42Would you rather

    or

  5. 43Would you rather

    or

  6. 44Would you rather

    or

  7. 45Would you rather

    or

  8. 46Would you rather

    or

  9. 47Would you rather

    or

  10. 48Would you rather

    or

  11. 49Would you rather

    or

  12. 50Would you rather

    or

How you compare

Vote on a few questions and your results show up here.

How to play

  • Turn the lights down and read each question by flashlight.
  • Have the reader pause for three seconds before the second option to build suspense.
  • After each vote, have players describe the first thing they'd do in the scene they picked.
  • At a campfire, read one question between each ghost story.
  • Let anyone skip a question that feels too creepy, and switch to the friendly-spooky creatures if the room gets tense.

Playing in a group? Read a question out loud, let everyone pick a side, then tap the one the room chose and see how it compares with everyone online.

Questions people ask

Are these scary would you rather questions okay for kids?

They're spooky but never gory, with no blood, injuries or violent scenes. Older kids and teens tend to enjoy them, and younger kids can start with the friendly-spooky ones, like helping a lost mummy find its way home.

What is a good scary would you rather question?

A good one makes both options creepy in different ways, like waking at 3 a.m. to someone whispering your name or to slow footsteps upstairs. It works best when players can picture the scene and feel a little shiver either way.

How do you play scary would you rather at a sleepover?

Dim the lights, take turns reading a question by flashlight, and have everyone vote at the same time. Ask each person what they'd do next in the scene they picked, and stop whenever someone has had enough.

More questions to vote on

Funny150 questionsCrazy and weird120 questionsGross80 questionsSuperpowers60 questionsThis or that300 questionsFor kids201 questionsFor couples150 questionsHard120 questions Play one at a timeRandom questions from every list